AAAmaury Abreu

The City Should Not Own the Homes It Wants to Save. It Should Give the Community the Ability to Own Them

By Amaury Abreu

Councilmember Jamie Gauthier has proposed that the city commit funding to buy and preserve 925 affordable homes in West and Southwest Philadelphia, homes owned by Neighborhood Restorations whose affordability protections are expiring. When affordable apartments are at risk of being lost, a normal instinct a city official may have is that the city should step in and buy them, and I think this instinct comes from a good place, because the fear underneath it is real and many people do not want to watch families lose homes that the market will never replace at the same price. There are models like the Kensington Corridor Trust, where the community owns the properties the trust owns. I support this idea instead of the concept that the local government should buy properties. If the government wants the community to have a chance at keeping homes affordable, then the local government should give the community the tools it needs for collective ownership.

Philadelphia's challenge is not a shortage of concern, because it is clear that the Council and the Mayor care about making our city an affordable place to live. I have discussed this in other essays, but as a city we need to move from a place of managing poverty to a place of increasing our constituents' ability to earn more income. We do not fix the issue of affordability by managing poverty, and we fix it by providing constituents with opportunities to grow within the industries that will shape our futures.

If the city wants to keep homes affordable, then it needs to find models that have already worked and emulate them, and the Kensington Corridor Trust is an example of that model. I believe collective ownership using the model that the Kensington Corridor Trust is using could be developed in other parts of the city, where people who rent their homes can become part owners of a larger portfolio and the community can work together on supporting each other when renovation needs arise.

I believe in private ownership of assets, and the government can facilitate the private collective ownership of those assets while respecting private markets. Investors and developers need to be interested in the Philadelphia market, and if the local government steps in and tries to own properties and manage them to keep them affordable, that affects the market.

Private collective ownership of assets is an idea that is hardly explored, and I think Philadelphia has an opportunity to develop ways for the community to own assets that are acquired the right way. Over time, this provides a way for the community to vote on things like what type of business will be in the community, renovating a house that is in bad condition, paying for necessary repairs and services to ensure the homes are in good condition, or selling a portion of the assets when the community agrees it is the right choice.

Government-owned and controlled property or businesses, like the proposed city-owned grocery store, are not good ideas, but privately and collectively owned property and businesses, facilitated by the city government, could be a better way of maintaining quality and affordability for all.

Support the Builders Fund

The Amaury Abreu Builders Fund supports candidates who champion builders and practices issue advocacy at the federal, state, and local level.

Paid for by Amaury Abreu Builders Fund. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee.